SCENARIO
Please use the following to answer the next question;
Miraculous Healthcare is a large medical practice with multiple locations in California and Nevad
a. Miraculous normally treats patients in person, but has recently decided to start offering telehealth appointments, where patients can have virtual appointments with on-site doctors via a phone app.
For this new initiative. Miraculous is considering a product built by MedApps. a company that makes quality telehealth apps for healthcare practices and licenses them to be used with the practices" branding. MedApps provides technical support for the app. which it hosts in the cloud MedApps also offers an optional benchmarking service for providers who wish to compare their practice to others using the service
Riya is the Privacy Officer at Miraculous, responsible for the practice s compliance with HIPAA and other applicable laws, and she works with the Miraculous procurement team to get vendor agreements in place. She occasionally assists procurement in vetting vendors and inquiring about their own compliance practices. as well as negotiating the terms of vendor agreements Riya is currently reviewing the suitability of the MedApps app from a pnvacy perspective
Riya has also been asked by the Miraculous Healthcare business operations team to review the MedApps' optional benchmarking service. Of particular concern is the requirement that Miraculous Healthcare upload information about the appointments to a portal hosted by MedApps
Which of the following would accurately describe the relationship of the parties if they enter into a contract for use of the app?
Answer : D
Under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), entities involved in the handling of protected health information (PHI) are classified as either covered entities or business associates based on their roles and activities.
Definitions Under HIPAA:
Covered Entity (CE):
A healthcare provider, health plan, or healthcare clearinghouse that creates, receives, maintains, or transmits PHI.
Miraculous Healthcare qualifies as a covered entity because it is a medical practice directly providing healthcare services to patients.
Business Associate (BA):
An organization or individual that performs functions, activities, or services involving the use or disclosure of PHI on behalf of a covered entity.
MedApps qualifies as a business associate because it is providing a telehealth app service to Miraculous, which involves hosting and maintaining PHI (e.g., appointment details, patient information).
Analysis of the Relationship:
Miraculous Healthcare: As the healthcare provider, it is responsible for patient care and compliance with HIPAA. Since it directly provides healthcare services to patients, it is the covered entity in this scenario.
MedApps: Although MedApps designed, hosts, and supports the telehealth app, it is providing these services on behalf of Miraculous Healthcare. As such, MedApps is a business associate under HIPAA. This designation requires MedApps to comply with HIPAA regulations through a Business Associate Agreement (BAA), ensuring that it appropriately safeguards the PHI it handles on behalf of Miraculous Healthcare.
Consideration of the Benchmarking Service:
The optional benchmarking service also reinforces MedApps' role as a business associate. Miraculous Healthcare would need to assess whether the PHI uploaded for benchmarking meets HIPAA's minimum necessary standard and that MedApps implements appropriate safeguards for PHI used for benchmarking. The BAA would need to address these specific uses.
Explanation of Options:
A . Miraculous Healthcare would be the covered entity because its name and branding are on the app. MedApps would be a business associate because it is hosting the data that supports the app: While this is close, it oversimplifies the reasoning by focusing solely on branding. The covered entity designation is determined by the healthcare services provided, not just branding.
B . MedApps would be the covered entity because it built and hosts the app and all the data. Miraculous Healthcare would be a business associate because it only provides its brand on the app: This is incorrect because MedApps is not directly providing healthcare services. Hosting and maintaining PHI does not make it a covered entity but rather a business associate.
C . Miraculous Healthcare would be a covered entity because it is the healthcare provider; MedApps would also be a covered entity because the data in the app is being shared with it: This is incorrect because MedApps does not independently provide healthcare services to patients. Its role is solely as a service provider to Miraculous.
D . Miraculous Healthcare would be the covered entity because it is the healthcare provider; MedApps would be a business associate because it is providing a service to support Miraculous: This is the correct answer. Miraculous is the covered entity, and MedApps, by hosting the telehealth app and handling PHI on Miraculous' behalf, is a business associate.
Reference from CIPP/US Materials:
HIPAA Privacy Rule (45 CFR 160.103): Defines covered entities and business associates.
Business Associate Agreements (BAAs): HIPAA requires a BAA between covered entities and business associates to ensure PHI is appropriately protected.
IAPP CIPP/US Certification Textbook: Provides detailed examples of covered entities and business associates, along with their roles and responsibilities under HIPAA.
Under the EU-US Data Privacy Framework, what must participating organizations provide to individuals in regard to complaints and disputes?
Answer : A
Under the EU-US Data Privacy Framework (DPF), organizations that participate in the framework must provide individuals with a way to resolve complaints and disputes about how their personal data is handled. Specifically, organizations are required to offer an independent recourse mechanism to ensure compliance with the principles of the framework. This mechanism enables individuals to bring their complaints forward and have them addressed through an impartial and accessible process.
The independent recourse mechanism is critical to the DPF as it reinforces accountability and builds trust in cross-border data transfers. Organizations must select a third-party dispute resolution provider (such as an alternative dispute resolution body or a regulatory body) and disclose this mechanism in their privacy policies. The mechanism must be provided free of charge to the individual.
Explanation of Options:
A . An independent recourse mechanism: This is the correct answer, as it is explicitly required under the EU-US Data Privacy Framework for resolving disputes and complaints related to data privacy.
B . A copy of the individual's personal data: While data access rights are part of broader privacy regulations (e.g., GDPR), this is not specific to the EU-US DPF's requirements regarding complaint handling.
C . A description of the organization's data processing policies: While transparency about data processing is an important requirement under the DPF, it does not address the need for a formal dispute resolution mechanism.
Which of the following is NOT a common challenge large organizations face when implementing data portability?
Answer : D
When implementing data portability, organizations often face significant challenges due to the complexity of managing data transfers. These challenges commonly include concerns about third-party data, technical compatibility for data transmission, and security considerations. However, the technical skillsets available in the transmitting organization is NOT typically identified as a primary challenge because most organizations have or can acquire the necessary technical expertise through training or by outsourcing.
Explanation of Options:
A . The presence of third-party data in the data to be ported: This is a valid challenge, as the inclusion of third-party data can raise legal and contractual concerns about ownership and transferability.
B . Technically compatible systems for transmission feasibility: Ensuring that data can be transferred between systems in compatible formats is a critical and common challenge.
C . Security considerations in relation to the transfer of the data: Data transfers must be secure to prevent unauthorized access or breaches, making this a valid challenge.
D . The technical skillsets available in the transmitting organization: While technical skills are important, organizations usually have the ability to address this issue through hiring, training, or outsourcing, making this the least common challenge.
Reference from CIPP/US Materials:
IAPP CIPP/US Certification Textbook: Discusses operational challenges related to data portability, including system compatibility, data security, and third-party involvement.
NIST Privacy Framework: Addresses organizational readiness and data transfer risks.
The concept of data portability refers to what?
Answer : C
The concept of data portability refers to an individual's right to access and transfer their personal data from one organization to another. It enables individuals to obtain and reuse their personal data for their own purposes across different services. For example, an individual can request their data from one service provider and transfer it to another provider, facilitating competition and giving consumers more control over their data.
This right is commonly associated with General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) but is becoming more widely discussed in U.S. privacy contexts, such as under the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and similar state laws. Although the CCPA does not explicitly mention 'data portability,' the concept aligns with its provision that grants individuals the right to access their data in a portable and usable format.
Explanation of Options:
A . The practice of disclosing all the data sources one organization uses to enhance data collection from different social media platforms: This describes a data disclosure practice, not data portability.
B . The technical measures organizations use to empower consumers' control in case data is being transferred to service providers: This refers to technical controls but does not fully capture the essence of data portability.
C . The ability of individuals to obtain and reuse their personal data for their own purposes across different services: This is the correct answer and accurately defines data portability.
D . The ability of individuals to easily change to another similar service provider if fees are unlawfully being raised: While data portability might facilitate switching providers, it is not specifically tied to the issue of unlawful fee increases.
Reference from CIPP/US Materials:
GDPR Article 20: Provides the right to data portability in the EU.
CCPA Section 1798.100: Requires businesses to provide personal data in a readily usable format upon request.
IAPP CIPP/US Certification Textbook: Discusses data portability as part of consumer rights and privacy frameworks.
Under GLB
Answer : D
Under the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA), financial institutions are required to provide their customers with an annual privacy notice that explains how they collect, share, and protect customers' personal information. However, the GLBA Privacy Rule (16 CFR Part 313) was amended by the Fixing America's Surface Transportation Act (FAST Act) in 2015, which introduced an exception to this requirement.
According to the FAST Act, financial institutions are not required to provide annual privacy notices if they meet two conditions:
No changes have been made to their privacy policy or practices since the last notice was sent to customers.
The financial institution does not share customers' nonpublic personal information with nonaffiliated third parties in a way that triggers an opt-out requirement under GLBA.
Explanation of Options:
A . An insurance company that has no privacy department: This is irrelevant. The requirement to provide privacy notices depends on whether the organization falls under GLBA's definition of a 'financial institution' and their compliance with privacy practices, not on the presence of a privacy department.
B . An auction house that also acts as a financial institution: If the auction house qualifies as a financial institution under GLBA (e.g., if it arranges financing), it would still need to comply with GLBA privacy requirements, including issuing annual privacy notices unless it qualifies for the exception.
C . A credit union that has made changes to its privacy notice from last year: If any changes are made to the privacy policy, the credit union must issue an updated privacy notice to its customers.
D . A credit union that has not made changes to its privacy notice from last year: This is the correct answer. If the credit union has not made any changes to its privacy notice and meets the FAST Act exception criteria (outlined above), it is not required to issue an annual privacy notice.
Reference from CIPP/US Materials:
GLBA Privacy Rule (16 CFR Part 313): This rule outlines the requirements for financial institutions to provide privacy notices.
FAST Act (2015) Amendment to GLBA Privacy Rule: This amendment introduced exceptions to the annual notice requirement for institutions that meet specific criteria.
IAPP CIPP/US Certification Textbook: Details the conditions under which GLBA exceptions apply and describes how the FAST Act impacted annual privacy notice requirements.
Mega Corp. is a U.S.-based business with employees in California, Virginia, and Colorado. Which of the following must Mega Corp. comply with in regard to its human resources data?
Answer : D
Mega Corp. is a U.S.-based business with employees in California, Virginia, and Colorado. Therefore, it must comply with the privacy laws of these three states in regard to its human resources data, unless it qualifies for an exemption under each law.
The California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA) is an amendment to the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) that was approved by voters in November 2020 and will take effect on January 1, 2023. The CPRA expands the rights and protections of California residents with respect to their personal information and creates a new category of sensitive personal information that includes certain employment-related data, such as Social Security numbers, driver's license numbers, passport numbers, financial account information, biometric information, and geolocation data. The CPRA also establishes a new enforcement agency, the California Privacy Protection Agency, to oversee and enforce the law.
The Virginia Consumer Data Protection Act (VCDPA) is a comprehensive privacy law that was enacted in March 2021 and will take effect on January 1, 2023. The VCDPA grants Virginia residents several rights with respect to their personal data, such as the right to access, correct, delete, port, and opt out of certain processing activities. The VCDPA also imposes various obligations on businesses that control or process personal data of Virginia residents, such as conducting data protection assessments, entering into contracts with processors, and providing privacy notices.
The Colorado Privacy Act (CPA) is another comprehensive privacy law that was enacted in July 2021 and will take effect on July 1, 2023. The CPA grants Colorado residents similar rights as the VCDPA, with some variations, such as the right to appeal a business's response to a request and the right to opt out of targeted advertising, the sale of personal data, and certain profiling activities. The CPA also imposes similar obligations as the VCDPA, with some differences, such as requiring opt-in consent for the processing of sensitive data and allowing businesses to join a universal opt-out mechanism.
All three laws apply to businesses that conduct business in or target consumers in the respective states and meet certain thresholds of revenue or data processing volume. However, all three laws also provide exemptions for certain types of data or entities that are subject to other federal or state laws, such as the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA), the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA), the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), and the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA).
One of the exemptions that may be relevant for Mega Corp. is the employee data exemption, which excludes personal data that is collected and used by an employer within the context of an employment relationship or for emergency contact or benefits administration purposes. However, this exemption is not permanent or uniform across the three laws. The CPRA's employee data exemption is set to expire on January 1, 2023, unless extended by the legislature. The VCDPA's employee data exemption is set to expire on January 1, 2023, unless repealed by the legislature. The CPA's employee data exemption does not have an expiration date, but it does not apply to the right to opt out of the sale of personal data or the right to appeal a business's response to a request.
Therefore, depending on the type and scope of the human resources data that Mega Corp. collects and processes, it may have to comply with the California Privacy Rights Act, the Virginia Consumer Data Protection Act, and the Colorado Privacy Act, unless it qualifies for another exemption under each law.
[IAPP CIPP/US Study Guide], Chapter 10: State Data Security Laws, pp. 227-229.